Gifts from Pharmaceutical Companies Are Still Okay with Some Docs
Thursday, July 8, 2010 at 3:08PM Reposted from the AMA's amednews:
A recent study finds that many physicians are okay with receiving certain types of gifts from pharmaceutical representatives, even if their institution does not.
Most physicians and doctors-in-training still have a positive attitude toward marketing-oriented activities by pharmaceutical companies and device manufacturers, even though some institutions and national specialty societies have adopted policies that limit or ban such practices, a new study shows.
For example, 72% of 590 surveyed doctors and medical students said sponsored lunches were appropriate, according to the study in the June Archives of Surgery. Nearly 60% said samples improve care for their patients, and 71% said pharmaceutical and device company money is useful for funding residency programs.
There were limits, though. About three in four respondents believed gifts valuing more than $50 were unacceptable. Nearly 90% thought vacations were inappropriate.
Study authors in 2008 polled faculty and medical trainees at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine consortium, which includes 11 hospitals throughout New York City (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20566978/).
Mount Sinai School of Medicine implemented a policy in 2007 that bans or limits marketing-related interactions between physicians and industry. Other institutions have adopted similar limits, and some specialty societies, including the American Board of Internal Medicine, have adopted guidelines.
"We were surprised overall to find the positive attitudes, especially at our institution that has the restrictions in place," said study co-author and internist Deborah Korenstein, MD, an associate professor at Mount Sinai's medical school.
But a physician's specialty, training level and familiarity with guidelines about gifts from drug companies and medical device manufacturers can influence how positively he or she views the marketing.
Physicians from surgical specialties were more likely to have a positive attitude toward industry and more likely to deem as acceptable some gifts, such as residency funding and travel reimbursement for attending lectures, the study showed. Pediatricians held less favorable attitudes. And non-attending physicians held more positive attitudes toward receiving meals, textbooks and drug samples.
The study also found that educating physicians about policies may make them less accepting of gifts, even small ones. Physicians familiar with Mount Sinai's guidelines (54%) were less likely to agree that drug samples improve patient care compared with those who were not familiar with the policy.
"Our findings suggest the importance of physician education about the influence of industry, particularly for trainees and surgical specialists who may be less aware of the influence of industry and who may in fact be governed through their specialty bodies by more permissive guidelines," study authors wrote. "However, large changes in physician attitudes are likely to require shifts in the cultural environment of medicine."
We want to hear from the medical students, nurses, physicians and surgeons out there. Do YOU think some gifts from pharma reps are acceptable? If so, what kind of gifts? If not, why?
Reader Comments (5)
Thanks for the posting.there is something very unique and enjoyable about.
I am apreciating it replica iwc watches
very much.I have never read such a lovely article and replica omega watches
I am coming back tomorrow to continue reading.
Coach Outlet is amazing,as a coach handbag's lover i must to say Coach Outlet Online Store
's handbag is perfect,and original,because they take the item from Coach Factory Outlet,so the bag is incredible cheap,and i have bought one last week,i'm satisfied with it qulity and the price,so why not buy one on Coach Outlet Online,you must fall in love with Coach Outlet Online
Winning elections is a science in Russia, though not a particularly elegant one. Coach FactoryThe term polit-tekhnolog (political technologist) is, after all, a Russian neologism.Chanel Bags There are well-paid teams of them in Moscow who do nothing but hatch ways to confuse voters, skew results and, when necessary, stuff the ballot box. Reports of their handiwork have been rife ahead of Russia's parliamentary elections Coach Outleton Sunday, calling to mind the country's unofficial electoral mantra, which is usually Coach Outletattributed to Stalin: "It's not important how they vote. It's important who is counting." Louis VuittonSo with all this experience to draw from, with all these technologists available to help,Chanel Bags how did Moscow manage to screw up the ballot last weekend in the tiny Russian Coach Outletvassal state of South Ossetia?It should have been a cakewalk. Chanel HandbagsInsofar as South Ossetia even has an economy, it relies on trade with the Russian Coach Factory Storemilitary, which conquered the region from the Republic of Georgia after a weeklong war in 2008. If you check Google Maps,Louis Vuitton or ask the U.N., the region is still technically a part of Georgia.Chanel BagsThe region's budget comes almost exclusively from Russian aid, whichChanel Bags has added up to about a billion dollars since 2008, when Russia became the Chanel Bagsfirst to recognize South Ossetia as an independent state. Since then, only four other countries Coach Outlethave followed suit: Venezuela, Nicaragua and the two Pacific island nations of Tuvalu and Coach Factory OutletNauru, all in exchange for loans or other goodies from Moscow.Besides, Coach Outlet Onlinethe region has only 28,000 registered voters, most of whom hold Russian Coach Outletpassports and worship Russia for liberating them from Georgian rule. The region's Coach Factory OutletPresident, Eduard Kokoity, openly stated in 2008 that South Ossetia Coach Outletshould eventually become a part of Russian territory. So it seemed obvious that when Coach Factory StoreKokoity's term in office ran out this year, Russia's favored candidate Louis Vuitton Bagswould easily succeed him. It wouldn't require a lot of finesse on Russia's part, just a bit of old-fashioned campaigning. But even before the elections began, things started going wrong.
Unemployment benefits Coach Outlet are believed to have one of the most stimulative effects on the economy, the chief economist at